Does trust have a face

1 min read · September 18, 2026
New Power Labs

Philanthropy often says it invests in people. Venture capital says it invests in founders. Both assume they are backing potential.

Decades of psychological research suggest something more immediate can also be at work: appearance.

In 1972, psychologists Karen Dion, Ellen Berscheid, and Elaine Walster described what became known as the "what is beautiful is good" stereotype: people attributed more desirable qualities to individuals they considered physically attractive, even when they had no evidence that those qualities existed.

Nearly 30 years later, a landmark meta-analysis by Judith Langlois and colleagues reviewed hundreds of studies involving thousands of participants. The pattern persisted across cultures and age groups: attractive people were consistently assumed to possess more socially desirable characteristics and were treated more favourably than less attractive peers.

The effects extend well beyond first impressions. Economist Daniel Hamermesh found a relationship between physical attractiveness and economic outcomes, including hiring and earnings. Appearance can quietly shape economic opportunity.

In philanthropy, trust can be particularly consequential. Grantmakers often describe funding decisions in relational terms: chemistry, trust, confidence in a leader's ability to deliver. Those qualities matter. But if we unconsciously associate attractiveness with competence, funding decisions risk being shaped by signals that have little to do with a leader's potential.

A 2024 study of 17 major high- and ultra-high-net-worth donors found that 16 emphasized the importance of trusting a charity's leadership. Trust was frequently used as a proxy for evidence, and nearly all participants relied on recommendations from people they trusted when deciding where to give. In a related study, half of the donors described relying on their gut or a "smell test," while 15 of 17 sought the endorsement of trusted friends or colleagues.

In a 2014 study, researchers analyzed 90 pitches from three entrepreneurial competitions and then tested the effect through controlled experiments. Male entrepreneurs were more likely to succeed in the competitions, particularly when they were physically attractive. In the experiments, participants preferred pitches presented by men even when the content was identical, and physical attractiveness increased the persuasiveness of male entrepreneurs.

The challenge is that appearance rarely announces itself as a criterion. No investment committee says it funded the more attractive founder. Instead, appearance can travel under other names: confidence, credibility, leadership, chemistry, trust. The judgment feels substantive even when part of what produced it may have nothing to do with the underlying opportunity.

None of this means trust is irrelevant. The people leading an organization matter enormously. But it raises a harder question: when we say we trust a leader, what exactly are we responding to?

The biases that shape capital allocation may not always sit in the criteria we choose, but in how we interpret them.

We often assume we are funding potential. Sometimes we are funding perception.

 

Narinder
New Power Labs

Like what you’re reading? Subscribe to get weekly Equity Shots in your inbox.

Previous
Previous

When funders give up their vote

Next
Next

Accountability and aspiration